Should Predestination Be Preached? Calvin’s Answer to Soft Critics

The question is not what contemporary culture thinks but what scripture teaches. Finally, there are criticisms that although not completely rejecting predestination, argue that Calvin emphasizes it too much to the detriment of other equally important doctrines. They argue that predestination, although true, is a theme that should not be preached frequently as it can lead to unintended conclusions. Calvin responds that all biblical truth must be proclaimed and that predestination being taught by scripture should not be silenced. One of the most consoling and transforming consequences of the Calvinist doctrine of predestination is the absolute assurance of salvation. For John Calvin, the understanding that we were chosen by God before the foundation of the world is not merely an abstract intellectual concept. It is a truth that produces unshakable confidence, a profound peace, and a certainty that transcends all external circumstances. Assurance of salvation in Calvin is not based on changing emotional feelings, nor on external circumstances that constantly fluctuate. It is based on God’s immutable will and eternal decree. If God chose me before the foundation of the world, then my salvation was not left to chance. It does not depend on my ability to maintain faith or on my moral performance. It depends on the will of a God who is infinitely wise, infinitely powerful, and infinitely faithful. Calvin repeatedly emphasizes that assurance of salvation is an immeasurable privilege and consolation for the believer in a world full of uncertainties and threats.